Skip to main content

Hundreds missing in Aleppo after fleeing eastern districts, says UN

The UN human rights office also voiced concerns that rebels were preventing civilians from leaving eastern Aleppo
Syrian residents fleeing the violence gather at a checkpoint manned by pro-government forces in the village of Aziza on the southwest outskirts of Aleppo (AFP)

The UN human rights office voiced concern on Friday that hundreds of men may have gone missing after fleeing eastern Aleppo into government-controlled parts of the city.

"While it's very difficult to establish the facts in such a fluid and dangerous situation, we have received very worrying allegations that hundreds of men have gone missing after crossing into government-controlled areas," rights office spokesman Rupert Colville told reporters in Geneva.

"Given the terrible record of arbitrary detention, torture and disappearances, we are of course deeply concerned."

'Given the terrible record of arbitrary detention, torture and disappearances, we are of course deeply concerned'

- Rupert Colville, UN

He added that there were around 150 activists inside east Aleppo who feared being detained by government forces if they attempt to leave.

The warning comes after Russia's foreign minister said on Thursday that the Syrian army had stopped active military operations in eastern Aleppo in light of a large effort to remove civilians from the city, RIA news agency reported.

Sergei Lavrov added that it had been agreed that Russian and US military experts would meet in Geneva on Saturday to discuss the situation in Aleppo.

"I can tell you that today, combat operations by the Syrian army have been halted in eastern Aleppo because there is a large operation under way to evacuate civilians," he said in Hamburg, cited by Russian news agencies.

"There is going to be to a column of 8,000 evacuees" travelling 5km, the Russian minister said.

MEE sources inside east Aleppo disputed the statement, saying fighting was continuing inside the city. Footage has emerged of what is alleged to be a chemical weapons attack on Thursday:
Colville also warned that rebel forces are preventing civilians from fleeing besieged eastern Aleppo, following the declaration of a halt in military operations by the Russian foreign minister.

"Some of the civilians who are attempting to flee are reportedly being blocked by armed opposition groups," Colville told reporters in Geneva.

He said the civilians were being "used as pawns" by armed groups in the area.

Allegations that rebel forces in eastern Aleppo were preventing civilians from leaving the enclave have surfaced a number of times during the conflict - in July, after the negotiation of humanitarian corridors, governor of Aleppo province Mohammad Marwan Olabi claimed that the rebels were preventing civilians from leaving.

Sources close to Middle East Eye also confirmed that civilians were being prevented from leaving, with one activist suggesting that it would be seen as "surrender" if civilians were allowed to leave. He added, however, that medical evacuations were being allowed to leave and pointed out that government forces were blocking two crossings into west Aleppo.

'Wait and see'

The US said it would "wait and see" if the the Russian statement on the cessation of hostilities was genuine.

"Our approach from the beginning has been to listen carefully to what the Russians say but scrutinise their actions," White House spokesman Josh Earnest said.

"So obviously that statement is an indication that something positive could happen, but we're going to have to wait and see whether those statements are reflected on the ground."

The State Department, meanwhile, said that Lavrov had agreed with his US counterpart John Kerry to "continue discussions about establishing a framework for a ceasefire that will allow the delivery of aid, as well as the safe departure of those who wish to leave the city".

The Russian claims came hours after the Red Cross said it had managed to evacuate almost 150 civilians, most of whom were disabled or in urgent need of care, from a hospital in the Old City of Aleppo where fighting had raged for days.

The evacuations were conducted with the help of members of the Syrian Arab Red Crescent.

Dar al-Safaa, originally a home for the elderly whose role expanded because of the crisis, had been accommodating patients with mental health needs or physical disabilities.

Three dozen other civilians, a number of them injured, had also sought refuge there.

“These patients and civilians had been trapped in the area for days because of heavy clashes nearby and as the front line kept drawing closer,” said the Red Cross's head in Syria, Marianne Gasser, who is currently in Aleppo.

“Many of them cannot move and need special attention and care. It must have been terrifying for them. Our partners from the Syrian Arab Red Crescent had been trying to reach and evacuate them since Tuesday.”

IS advance towards Palmyra

Meanwhile, the Islamic State (IS) group in Syria attacked the Syrian army near the city of Palmyra on Thursday, killing dozens of soldiers and advancing to within 4km of the city, a war monitor said.

The Syrian army, backed by Russian jets, recaptured Palmyra, the site of a Roman-era city and spectacular ruins, from IS in March after the group seized it in May 2015.

On Thursday, militants gained control over Qasr al-Halabat, southwest of Palmyra; Jabal Hayan, to the west; South Sawamea to the northeast and the Hawaisis region to the northwest, the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said.

At least 34 Syrian soldiers were killed, including at least eight officers, and there were also deaths on the IS side, the Observatory said.

IS has been on its back foot in both Syria and Iraq since late last year, losing much of its territory in both countries, as some of its most senior figures have been killed in air strikes.

A US military official said at least 50,000 IS fighters had been killed by the US-led coalition since it began operations in Iraq and Syria in late 2014.

"I am not into morbid counts but that kind of volume matters, that kind of impact on the enemy," the official said, calling the 50,000 number a "conservative estimate".

New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch

Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters

Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.