Skip to main content

Navigational error to blame in Iran incident: Pentagon

'A navigational error of some kind' led to the two small patrol boats ending up in Iranian water
Iran’s Revolutionary Guards while en route from Kuwait to Bahrain apprehended the vessels (AFP)
By AFP

A navigational error caused two US Navy vessels to stray into Iranian waters, Pentagon chief Ashton Carter said on Thursday, as opponents of the Obama administration voiced increasing anger over the US response to the incident.

Carter provided no detail but said "a navigational error of some kind" led to the two small patrol boats ending up in Iranian water on Tuesday. The military had initially blamed mechanical problems.

Iran’s Revolutionary Guards apprehended the vessels while they were en route from Kuwait to Bahrain. Ten sailors were held overnight before being released back to the United States. 

"We will find out more what combination of factors led to that navigational error, but they were clearly out of the position that they intended to be in," Carter said. 

Critics of the Obama administration are livid over the affair, saying it demonstrates weakness in the face of Iranian aggression.

Video showing the US sailors kneeling and with their hands clasped behind their heads, and one of them apologising, aired on US television Wednesday, further angering lawmakers. 

Carter, speaking at a news conference in Florida, deflected questions on whether Iran had breached the Geneva Convention by showing images of the captured sailors.

"Obviously I don't like to see our people detained by a foreign military," Carter said. 

"What we don't know is the full context. What you are looking through is the lens of the Iranian media. We need to give these guys the opportunity to tell us what was really going on and what the overall context is before we can really know."

Video also showed Iranian troops rummaging through an array of weapons found aboard the US boats.

General Lloyd Austin, who oversees the US military's Central Command, said the Iranians had "largely" returned the US equipment.  

"For the most part, the gear we deployed with was largely there when we got the boats back," he said. 

"Whether or not there was a singular piece of equipment missing, we'll determine that once we have completed the inventories," he added.

New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch

Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters

Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.