Mohammed al-Alami killing: Video shows Israeli soldiers had 'no reason to open fire', says B'Tselem
Videos of the moment when Israeli soldiers opened fire at a Palestinian car in the southern occupied West Bank town of Beit Ummar last month, killing 12-year-old Mohammed al-Alami, shows that Israeli forces had “no reason to open fire”, human rights group B’Tselem has stated.
The Israeli rights group released security camera footage on Tuesday of the moment when Israeli soldiers ran towards the car driven by Mohammed’s father, Moayyad al-Alami, at the entrance of Beit Ummar on 28 July, before spraying bullets in the direction of the vehicle in which three children were sitting.
Relatives told Middle East Eye last month that Moayyad had been driving home from the grocery store with Mohammed and his younger siblings Anan, 8, and Ahmed, 5, when they stumbled on a group of Israeli soldiers at the entrance of the town - a familiar sight for the family, whose home is located only 50 metres from a permanent Israeli military base.
As Moayyad approached the entrance to his family's neighbourhood, Mohammed reportedly begged his father to go to the corner store to buy some sweets before they went home for lunch. Moayyad happily obliged, and began turning the car around - but moments after he put the car into reverse, soldiers began to shout and rushed towards the intersection where he had made his turn, firing live bullets at the car while shocked neighbours and relatives looked on.
The videos released by B’Tselem this week corroborated the family’s version of events, showing the Alami family’s car stopping at the intersection, far from the soldiers, before changing direction - only for soldiers to then run in the direction of the car and firing at the vehicle.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
“The choice to open fire at the car, in the heart of a populated residential area, was unjustified, as none of the passengers posed a risk - to the soldiers or to any other person,” B’Tselem said in a statement.
The Israeli army said soldiers had mistaken the Alamis’ car for a vehicle wanted in a separate case involving the disposal of a dead baby’s body - a claim residents of Beit Ummar have rejected, while B’Tselem said such an explanation had “absolutely no bearing upon the shooting”.
The “heinous killing”, B’Tselem wrote, “demonstrates, yet again, how low the value of Palestinians’ lives is in the eyes of the soldiers, their commanders and the policymakers”.
According to Defence for Children International - Palestine (DCIP), Mohammed was the 11th Palestinian child to be killed by Israel in the West Bank in 2021, and the 78th Palestinian child to be killed by Israel anywhere this year.
A 20-year-old Palestinian, Shawkat Awad, was meanwhile killed by Israeli forces during Mohammed’s funeral on 29 July.
While Israeli authorities have stated that a military police investigation has been opened into Mohammed’s killing, international institutions have long pointed out that internal army investigations into fatal shootings of Palestinians rarely lead to legal charges or accountability.
Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.
