'An act of terrorism': Social media users react to Lebanon pager explosions
At least 12 people were killed and 2,750 wounded in Lebanon on Tuesday after pagers commonly used by Hezbollah - and medical personnel - exploded in unison, in an attack that the movement and Lebanese government blamed on Israel.
As Lebanon continues to pull itself together after the shock of what Hezbollah called its "biggest security breach" since escalations with Israel increased in October, Lebanese citizens and thousands around the globe have taken to social media to convey the ongoing chaos on the ground, as well as the increasingly materialising fears of an all-out war.
In Lebanon, citizens explained what it was like during the attack.
Soon after the thousands of pagers exploded in unison, BBC journalist Nafiseh Kohnavard pointed out the heavy presence of ambulances all over Beirut.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
It’s a very strange situation here in all over Beirut. We can see the army deployed to multiple areas. On our way to downtown saw several ambulances/civil defence teams rushing towards locations that pager explosions has happened
— Nafiseh Kohnavard (@nafisehkBBC) September 17, 2024
Hospitals in Beirut quickly neared full capacity as thousands of wounded people were rushed into emergency rooms with various injuries.
At least 2,800 people have been wounded and nine people killed in Lebanon after pagers used by Hezbollah exploded, Lebanese Health Minister Firass Abiad said. Hezbollah said people were killed and wounded by "mysterious explosions" of pagers across "various Hezbollah units and… pic.twitter.com/FTdiLjuulo
— Middle East Eye (@MiddleEastEye) September 17, 2024
From inside a hospital, Lebanese doctor Danie El Hallak explained the harrowing state of those who were injured.
I smelled too much blood today and tried to stop many slaughtered body parts from bleeding (which was pointless).. what we are going through is unbelievable
— Dania El Hallak, MD (@Daniaalhalllak) September 17, 2024
Lebanon’s Health Minister Firas Abiad said most of the injuries were "either in the face, especially in the eyes, or in the hands, or in the abdomen", which Hallak echoed in her posts.
A victim was rushed to be triaged in ER with his intestines out!! We tried to stabilize him until we could finally take him to OR. I had to remove bandages only to find no eyeballs in place. I saw people slaughtered for the first time. Can one ever recover from such sight?
— Dania El Hallak, MD (@Daniaalhalllak) September 17, 2024
Another social media user spoke about seeing a woman grieving her husband's potential loss of eyesight.
In a hospital in Dahye, a young woman was sitting surrounded by her grieving relatives & in-laws. She gently urged them not to cry & reassured them of her acceptance of whatever fate might bring… & she promised that if her husband were to lose his sight, she would be his eyes.
— د (@trhxianl) September 17, 2024
Among the dead was a 10-year-old girl, who was killed in eastern Lebanon's Bekaa Valley when the pager of her father, who is allegedly a Hezbollah member, exploded. Many have posted a photo of the girl on their X accounts and Instagram stories to pay their condolences.
'A reckless indiscriminate attack'
Reactions from across the globe have been pouring in, condemning the attack.
Several social media users drew attention to the reckless and casual nature of the attack which targeted many people including civilians. A human rights lawyer on X cited the International Humanitarian Law Databases of the ICRC, saying that “there was no way to know if they would be in shopping markets, homes, or streets with busy traffic”, pointing to the indiscriminate nature of the attack.
There is no world in which the explosion of hundreds, if not thousands, of pagers is not an indiscriminate attack prohibited by international law.
— Mai El-Sadany (@maitelsadany) September 17, 2024
When those pagers were set off, there was no way to know if they would be in shopping markets, homes, or streets with busy traffic. pic.twitter.com/g5shceuosa
Author Dyab Abou Jahjah pointed out that many of the pagers that exploded were not just owned by Hezbollah fighters, but civilians that are employed by Hezbollah's institutions.
Important notice:
— Dyab Abou Jahjah (@Aboujahjah) September 17, 2024
The pagers that exploded in Lebanon were not solely used by resistance fighters; employees of Hezbollah's institutions, which include civilians, also used them. It's important to note that Hezbollah is a political party (part of the Lebanese government) and it…
Jahjah continued to say that "this implies that not only IDF soldiers but anyone associated with the Israeli state—civil servants, various employees, and politicians—could now become legitimate targets".
This is significant not just from a legal standpoint, but also in terms of the prevailing rules of engagement. Up to this point, both Hezbollah and Israel have maintained that their targets were limited to military personnel on the opposing side. Civilian casualties were…
— Dyab Abou Jahjah (@Aboujahjah) September 17, 2024
Anthropologist and researcher Philip Proudfoot cited a section on indiscriminate attacks of the ICRC Geneva Conventions of 1949 and said that Israel is committing a war crime due to the indiscriminate nature of this attack with possible collateral damage. Many other users cited the same section of the convention, drawing attention to the fact that people had no means of knowing who was holding the explosive devices when they went off.
Just so we are clear: Israel causing thousands of pagers to explode across Lebanon — with zero means of even *pretending* to know who was holding the device at that specific moment, or where they were, or possible collateral damage — is, as you’d expect, a serious war crime. pic.twitter.com/s9SQxqcPmB
— Philip Proudfoot (@PhilipProudfoot) September 17, 2024
Others, including journalist Owen Jones, condemned the hypocrisy of reactions from the international community on X, suggesting that “if Hezbollah blew up the phones or pagers of Israeli reservists, inevitably killing and maiming children and bystanders, those cheering on Israel now would be denouncing an obscene act of terrorism.”
Attacking personal devices in a manner that harms thousands and kills numerous civilians is a terror attack #lebanon
— Marc Owen Jones (@marcowenjones) September 17, 2024
Many users, like academic Yousef Munayyer, have taken to their accounts to express the precedent that this attack may have established in inspiring cyber attacks in the future, saying that it may have opened "pandora's box".
The apparent Israeli mass cyber attack in Lebanon that detonated cellular devices/pagers is a grave violation of international law and opens a dangerous pandoras box. Almost every human is a walking ticking bomb and it won't be long before this tech will be used by many actors
— Yousef Munayyer (@YousefMunayyer) September 17, 2024
Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.