Skip to main content

Israel is 'critically ill' under Netanyahu, ex-spymasters warn

Mossad ex-chiefs voiced concerns over a bi-national state with the Palestinians which would spell the end of Israel as a 'Jewish state'
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu addresses a conference in Tel Aviv, 27 March (AFP)

Six former Israeli spymasters accused Benjamin Netanyahu on Tuesday of jeopardising the country's future as it prepares to celebrate the 70th anniversary of its founding on 14 of May.

The surviving ex-Mossad intelligence agency chiefs voiced their opinion of the fourth-term, right-wing prime minister in a joint interview excerpted on the front page of Yedioth Ahronoth, Israel's best-selling newspaper and a regular Netanyahu critic.

Netanyahu had no immediate response, but a senior member of his governing coalition brushed off the censure.

We are in a critical medical state... he has brought it to the grave condition of a malignant disease.

- Zvi Zamir, former Mossad director

Danny Yatom, who directed Mossad during Netanyahu's first stint in office in the late 1990s, called for his removal and accused him and his aides of "putting their interests ahead of national interests" as corruption investigations deepen.

Police questioned Netanyahu on Monday for four hours over allegations he offered to ease regulation of a telecoms company in return for favourable coverage in its owners' media outlets.

He was questioned by members of Lahav 433, an investigations unit known as the "Israeli FBI", at his residence on Balfour Street in West Jerusalem. He was previously questioned by police on 2 March in relation to "Case 4000", one of five cases currently being investigated in relation to the prime minister and his associates.

Netanyahu has denied any wrongdoing and opinion polls show his popularity is still high.

Yatom also voiced concern about "the inertia in the diplomatic sphere, which is leading us toward a bi-national state (with the Palestinians), which would spell the end of (Israel as) a Jewish and democratic state".

Negotiations over a "two-state solution" to Israel's conflict with the Palestinians have been frozen since 2014. Some argue that if Israel fails to quit occupied territory, it could one day face a choice between remaining a democracy or securing a Jewish majority by denying the Palestinians voting rights.

Figures cited by Israeli officials on Monday, 26 March showed the number of Israeli Jews and Palestinians between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River - territory encompassing Israel, the occupied West Bank and the Gaza Strip - is at or near parity.

"We have children and grandchildren and great-grandchildren here, and I want them to live in a healthy country - and the country is sick," Zvi Zamir, Mossad director from 1968 to 1974, was quoted as saying by Yedioth.

"We are in a critical medical state. It could be that the country had symptoms when Netanyahu took over, but he has brought it to the grave condition of a malignant disease."

Netanyahu's office did not immediately respond.

Naftali Bennett, the education minister and a hardliner in Israel's conservative coalition government, took to Twitter to dismiss the allegations aired by the ex-spymasters as "simply untrue".

"The country is in an excellent condition," said Bennett, who has cast himself as a possible successor to Netanyahu.

"Among most of our leadership, the good of the country is first and foremost... Israel is going in a good direction!"

New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch

Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters

Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.