Netanyahu's map erasing occupied West Bank sparks widespread condemnation
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has faced wide condemnation after showing a map that excluded the occupied West Bank in a news briefing on Monday.
The Israeli prime minister appeared standing in front of a wall-sized digital map where the occupied West Bank had been erased.
The Palestinian foreign ministry said the use of the map was “a blatant acknowledgement of Israel's colonial and racist agenda. The Ministry views this as a serious violation of international law, especially as Israel continues its war crimes against Palestinians aiming to deny their existence and their legitimate national rights.”
Netanyahu's Map Reveals the True Agenda of the Racist, Colonial Far-Right #Israeli Government
— State of Palestine - MFA 🇵🇸🇵🇸 (@pmofa) September 3, 2024
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Expatriates condemns the repeated use by Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu of a map that includes the #West_Bank as part of Israel, calling it a… pic.twitter.com/7Wu1lbjda2
In July 2024, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) issued an advisory opinion saying Israel's decades-long occupation of the Palestinian territories was "unlawful" and that its "near-complete separation" of people in the occupied West Bank breached international laws concerning "racial segregation" and "apartheid".
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
It is illegal under international law to take or build settlements in occupied territories.
Palestinian ambassador to the UK Husam Zomlot said that Benjamin Netanyahu’s erasure of the occupied West Bank from the map aims to erase the Palestinian people and take the rest of their land. He pointed out the irony of the situation, asking what would happen if a Palestinian politician did this.
Where is the West Bank on this map? Israeli PM showing that Israel’s aim is to erase the Palestinian people and take the rest of our land! Imagine if a Palestinian politician did this. pic.twitter.com/pTuH3vAkmj
— Husam Zomlot (@hzomlot) September 2, 2024
“The erasure of the West Bank is part of the same genocidal campaign as Gaza, a total assault on Palestinian existence made possible with US support,” Assal Rad, a historian of Middle East history, posted on the social media platform X.
It is wild that Netanyahu openly uses a map that erases the whole West Bank with little to no coverage or pushback from the West.
— Assal Rad (@AssalRad) September 2, 2024
The erasure of the West Bank is part of the same genocidal campaign as Gaza, a total assault on Palestinian existence made possible with US support. pic.twitter.com/LcdTvN9Nvm
Feminist grassroots organisation Code Pink also took to X, saying that “Israel plans to destroy all of Palestine and force Palestinians into Gaza, a shrinking concentration camp. This is an incitement of genocide. Where is the international alarm?”
Netanyahu shows a map without the West Bank, which Israel has occupied for 57 years.
— CODEPINK (@codepink) September 2, 2024
Israel plans to destroy all of Palestine and force Palestinians into Gaza, a shrinking concentration camp.
This is an incitement of genocide. Where is the international alarm? pic.twitter.com/lplzgV6wKG
Mairav Zonszein, a senior Israel analyst with the International Crisis Group, said that “this speech will go down in history as Netanyahu's open admission to that world that Israel will remain between the river and the sea indefinitely, as long as he rules”.
Of course, the West Bank does not exist on Netanyahu's map. And Gaza is the forever Israeli enclave.
— Mairav Zonszein מרב זונשיין (@MairavZ) September 2, 2024
This speech will go down in history as Netanyahu's open admission to that world that Israel will remain between the river and the sea indefinitely, as long as he rules. pic.twitter.com/JETV5X1WpR
Algeria’s national football team, Algeria FC, also joined the conversation, saying that “in case the genocide in Gaza wasn’t clear enough and you needed further proof of Israel’s plan to fully erase Palestine”.
The Prime Minister of Israel Benjamin Netanyahu using a map which doesn’t even acknowledge the existence of the West Bank 🇵🇸 is incredibly alarming.
— Algeria FC (@Algeria_FC) September 3, 2024
In case the genocide in Gaza wasn’t clear enough and you needed further proof of Israel’s plan to fully erase Palestine. pic.twitter.com/HTipHS6VOV
Journalist Rania Abouzeid said it was not the first time Netanyahu presented a map that "erases Palestinians".
Last night was not the first time Netanyahu has presented a map of Israel ‘from the river to the sea’ that erases Palestinian territories. He did so pre-October 7 at UNGA in Sept. 2023 (2nd pic) & has repeatedly said he has long opposed & worked to prevent a Palestinian state pic.twitter.com/FNvvn6TMwM
— Rania Abouzeid (@Raniaab) September 3, 2024
Pro-Palestinian activists and protesters have been regularly criticised for their use of the slogan "from the river to the sea", with critics going so far as to say the phrase is antisemitic. Journalist and filmmaker Robert Mackey pointed out that the incident was a physical manifestation of the phrase.
On Netanyahu's map, the entire West Bank (including East Jerusalem), where millions of Palestinians have lived under Israeli military occupation for 57 years, has been erased and the whole region outside Gaza is labelled "Israel." He stands by the river and points to the sea. https://t.co/U5oxWqcFOV
— Robert Mackey (@RobertMackey) September 2, 2024
“Benjamin Netanyahu is broadcasting his plans of ethnic cleansing and wanton destruction of Palestinian lives from the river to the sea clear… Yet the US, UK and EU will babble nonsense about pushing Israel towards a two-state solution while supplying him with the weapons to make his genocidal colonial plans a reality,” TV host and journalist Afshin Rattansi said on X.
Benjamin Netanyahu presents a map without the Palestinian West Bank, including the entire area in the map of Israel
— Afshin Rattansi (@afshinrattansi) September 3, 2024
Then the Israeli army declares the West Bank as a combat zone, and the second most important front after Gaza
Benjamin Netanyahu is broadcasting his plans of… pic.twitter.com/JbBmjYkRS1
Social media analyst, author and professor Marc Owen Jones said the threat of Palestinian erasure has accelerated since the Abraham Accords.
Remember Netanyahu showed a map of Israel that included ALL of Palestine to the UN weeks BEFORE October 7th. Palestinians have been facing erasure for decades, and that threat has only accelerated since the Abraham Accords pic.twitter.com/sm3GwynDbn
— Marc Owen Jones (@marcowenjones) September 3, 2024
At the United Nations General Assembly last September, Netanyahu presented a map showing a “new Middle East” where the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip appeared to be part of Israel.
An earlier erroneous map shown by Netanyahu also included the Palestinian territories as part of Israel in 1948.
Israel did not control the occupied West Bank, including East Jerusalem or the Gaza Strip, following its creation in 1948 on 80 percent of historic Palestine. It illegally occupied the territories in 1967 and continues to do so, in what is known as the longest occupation in modern history.
The inclusion of Palestinian lands, and at times land belonging to Syria and Lebanon, in Israeli maps is common among believers of the concept of Eretz Yisrael - Greater Israel - a key part of ultra-nationalist Zionism that claims all of these lands belong to a Zionist state.
Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.